Why large companies can't keep up with small business AI innovation

While corporate boardrooms debate AI governance frameworks and policy implementations, small businesses are quietly gaining a competitive advantage by simply getting on with using artificial intelligence, according to research.

Despite $30–$40 billion in enterprise GenAI (generative AI) investment, a staggering 95% of large organisations are getting absolutely no return on their AI spending, according to The GenAI Divide: State of AI in Business 2025 – MIT's analysis of 300 public implementations.

Contrast that with a recent report from VistaPrint, which found that AI adoption in small firms is actually growing enormously, with real efficiency gains driving the trend. The research found that sole traders are likely to benefit most of all.

Lead generation specialist and Enterprise Nation adviser Leisa Pickles, founder of independent sales consultancy Find me the Leads, believes policy paralysis at large companies is creating an unprecedented opportunity for nimble smaller firms.

She says:

"AI is moving quicker than businesses are able to implement policies and practices to teach their people how to use it properly.

"We make an assumption that big businesses have all the systems in place, but they really don't."

This stark divide between corporate investment and results creates what researchers call the "GenAI Divide" – and small businesses are finding themselves on the winning side.

The corporate investment paradox

The data reveals a troubling pattern: large enterprises lead in pilot volume but lag dramatically in scale-up.

While over 80% of organisations have explored tools like ChatGPT and Copilot, only 5% of integrated AI pilots are extracting millions in value from enterprise-grade systems.

The research also found 60% of organisations evaluated enterprise-grade AI tools, but only 20% reached pilot stage and just 5% reached production.

Most fail due to what the research identifies as "brittle workflows, lack of contextual learning, and misalignment with day-to-day operations" – something smaller firms don't have to deal with, Leisa says.

Small business: test, learn, move on

Small businesses operate with what Leisa describes as a "test, learn and refine" mentality that bypasses the corporate paralysis entirely.

"If we test it and it doesn't work, we'll just learn from it and move on to something else. In our world, if it doesn't work, it doesn't matter."

This experimental approach removes the fear factor that paralyses larger organisations.

Leisa explains:

"Large firms struggle with complex enterprise integrations and the core barrier to scaling isn't infrastructure, regulation, or talent – it's learning.

"I think larger businesses are struggling to implement a policy or a way of working that protects them from their teams all going off using different large language models (LLMs) and each time revealing a little bit more about their business in an uncontrolled way."

Leisa adds:

"They're almost not integrating it because they're not addressing the issue. What are the parameters? What system do we want to direct them towards? What information are they allowed to share?"

Leisa says small businesses naturally solve this problem through their agile approach. She's also seeing larger businesses avoiding tackling these policy questions, and simply outsourcing AI implementation.

"I use ChatGPT-5, email marketing platforms and automation to do their emails because it's easier for them to give it to me than it is for them to train and mobilise their whole team."

The authenticity dividend

The irony of AI, Leisa says, is that by using it to handle routine tasks, small businesses can focus on what large enterprises struggle to automate – authentic relationships and contextual expertise.

She says:

"What AI can't replace is experience, examples, that lived experience. Use AI to do the dull stuff and use your own lived experience to overlay the human element."

AI support with the tiring stuff

The MIT research shows that despite massive enterprise investment, only two of eight major sectors show meaningful structural change. Large companies are caught in what researchers call an "enterprise paradox" – leading in pilot volume but failing at deployment.

But small business owners face different pressures that actually help with adopting AI. Fatigue drives demand for AI solutions that simply work – they want solutions to help with the boring, tiring stuff and evaluate tools on this basis rather than software benchmarks, Leisa says.

VIDEO: How to combine human creativity with AI efficiency

In this webinar, learn how to combine human creativity with powerful, affordable AI tools to drive smarter, more cost-effective marketing:

Corporate resource paradox

The research reveals an investment bias where "budgets favour visible, top-line functions over high-ROI back office" operations.

Large companies throw money at high-profile AI initiatives while missing practical automation opportunities that small businesses embrace immediately.

Leisa explains:

"Bigger businesses that have money sometimes throw money at a problem. It's almost like, 'Well, if we just ignore it and give it to somebody else to do, maybe it will go away'."

Leisa's work with clients demonstrates the practical advantages that small businesses gain. She recently used AI tools to transform a tedious full-day process of building prospect lists.

"We've now found an AI tool that can assist us with that. We still need to overlay quality control, but it means we can just get on and do the good stuff, the added value stuff."

While most implementations inside businesses don't have any measurable impact, organisations that have crossed the GenAI Divide are seeing positive effects on the workforce and better customer retention through automated outreach – exactly the results Leisa delivers for clients.

Leisa's five AI adoption tips for small businesses

1. Match solutions to problems: "Map out what you want the system to do, what tasks, what output, who's using it, then find a system to fit that rather than the other way round."

2. Embrace the test-and-learn approach: Small businesses can afford to experiment. If something doesn't work, move on quickly without the policy paralysis that affects larger companies.

3. Focus on automating tasks you dislike: Use AI for the "dull stuff" like prospect research and routine communications, freeing time for high-value activities that require human experience.

4. Don't try to learn everything: Consider outsourcing AI implementation to specialists rather than trying to become experts in every tool yourself.

5. Maintain the human element: Use AI as an enabler for more authentic relationships, not as a replacement for personal experience and genuine connections.

Future implications

MIT's research suggests that while generic tools like ChatGPT boost individuals' productivity, enterprise-grade systems are being "quietly rejected" due to their complexity and poor fit with existing processes.

This creates a sustained advantage for agile small businesses that can adapt quickly and focus on outcomes rather than governance.

Leisa says:

"It's just made us more action-orientated because we have the enablers to do it. We can just get on and do the good stuff, the added value stuff."

For small businesses willing to experiment while their larger competitors burn through billions on failed pilots, AI represents not just efficiency gains, but a rare opportunity to outpace corporate giants through sheer pragmatic innovation.

The data suggests this advantage may be sustainable – large enterprises aren't failing due to lack of investment, but due to their approach. And changing approach is much easier for a small business than a corporate giant.

People also read

• How small businesses can leverage AI

• How to get started with AI in your small business

• AI is changing everything – here's how to get on board